The unveiling of the trailer for Avengers: Doomsday has reignited debates among Marvel fans, particularly about the return of Chris Evans as Steve Rogers. Many fans vocalized their displeasure online, stating that this move undermines the character development of Anthony Mackie’s Sam Wilson, who was handed the Captain America mantle in Avengers: Endgame. Critics argue that bringing back familiar faces like Steve Rogers appears to be a desperate attempt by Marvel to attract audiences at the risk of sidelining the newer heroes they have introduced. The trailer suggests that Steve Rogers will play a significant role, raising concerns about whether this diminishes Sam Wilson's journey to become Captain America. Both fans and critics have pointed out that this decision seems to disregard the emotional weight and passing of the shield from one hero to another, thereby lessening the impact of Sam’s struggle and accomplishments showcased in The Falcon and the Winter Soldier.

Why is the return of Chris Evans as Steve Rogers controversial among fans?

Fans find Chris Evans' return as Steve Rogers controversy because it undermines Anthony Mackie's character Sam Wilson, who took up the Captain America mantle. Many believe it diminishes the growth and development of newer characters introduced in recent Marvel films.

Avengers: Doomsday is part of a long-running Marvel Cinematic Universe, which has been critically scrutinized since the conclusion of the Infinity Saga with Avengers: Endgame. The franchise has attempted to bring fresh characters to the forefront, yet continues to rely on nostalgic figures from the previous phases of the MCU. This decision not only raises eyebrows but also highlights the ongoing tension between old and new narratives within the expansive Marvel universe, challenging how the franchise can evolve while satisfying its existing fan base.