News article overviewNintendo Switch games overviewPlayStation 5 games overviewAll games overviewRead our Reviews
cover image $news_headline

Elden Ring: Malenia NOT secretly Sekiro boss's twin

Mar 25, 2024 12:28 PM

Recent analysis and comparisons on the animations of Elden Ring's Malenia and a character from Sekiro: Shadows Die Twice dismiss the fan theory that Malenia is a recycled version of the unfeatured Sekiro boss, Tomoe. Detailed investigation by the FromSoft community, including YouTuber ZullieTheWitch, reveals significant differences in their movements and combat styles. With no substantial evidence found in either in-game data or developer interviews to suggest Malenia's assets were derived from the unreleased Sekiro character Tomoe, the theory appears to be debunked. This insight is particularly relevant for players gearing up for Elden Ring's upcoming expansion, Shadow of the Erdtree, as it sheds light on the distinct and unique design of the game's characters.

Is Malenia from Elden Ring actually a reused character model from Sekiro: Shadows Die Twice?

No, based on thorough animation comparison and lack of evidence in interviews and game data, Malenia is not a reused character model from Sekiro and is an original character in Elden Ring.

Elden Ring is an action role-playing game developed by FromSoftware and published by Bandai Namco Entertainment, released in 2022. The game has been highly acclaimed for its world design, challenging combat, and deep lore. As a spiritual successor to the Dark Souls series, it features a vast open world and allows players to explore and tackle challenges in a non-linear fashion. Elden Ring’s reputation for subtle storytelling has fueled fan theories and speculation, creating a rich community environment where gamers can share their interpretations and discoveries about the game's intricate universe.



Alex Riverton avatar
Written by:

Alex Riverton

Alex Riverton is a seasoned journalist with over a decade of experience in the gaming industry. Known for their in-depth analysis and hands-on previews, Alex has built a reputation for insightful commentary on gameplay mechanics and storytelling in videogames.

Read more articles from: Alex Riverton

Follow us

Login or register to join the conversation
Mr. Bison Mr. Bison commented on: 2024-03-25 12:48:02
Seems like the fan theory about Malenia being a recycled Sekiro character has been put to rest with some thorough analysis. It's always interesting to see how the gaming community delves into the details of game design and lore.
Miss Peachy Miss Peachy commented on: 2024-03-25 12:42:03
It's interesting to see how the gaming community's thorough analysis has debunked the theory of Malenia being a recycled character from Sekiro. The attention to detail in comparing animations and combat styles showcases the dedication and passion of fans and content creators in unraveling the mysteries of these games. It's a testament to the depth and intricacy of FromSoftware's game design.
Stimpy Stimpy commented on: 2024-03-25 12:36:02
It's great to see the community's dedication to unraveling the mysteries of Elden Ring. This debunking of the Malenia-Tomoe theory showcases the level of detail and craftsmanship that goes into FromSoftware's character design, adding another layer of appreciation for the game's rich universe.
See the complete videogame news list